Architecture Tactics

Intro

• How can we design an architecture that will achieve the desired quality attributes ?
• Sources of architecture
  • Theft: From previous systems, literature
  • Method: Systematic and conscious, derived from requirements via transformations and heuristics.
  • Intuition: Ability to conceive without conscious reasoning. Increased reliance on intuition increases the risk.
• Ratio of usage of above three methods varies according to architects experience and novelty.

• What is a tactic ? - A tactic is a design decision that influences the control of a quality attribute response.
• A collection of tactics is an architectural strategy.
• Each tactic is a design option for the architect.

Availability Tactics

• All approaches to maintaining availability involve some type of redundancy, some type of health monitoring and some type of recovery when a failure is detected.
• Faults cause failures. Availability tactics focus on dealing with faults.
• Availability tactics involve- Fault detection, fault recovery and fault prevention.

Fault Detection

• Ping/echo and hearbeat generally operate among distinct processes and the exception tactic operates within a single process.

Ping/Echo

• One component issues a ping to a component to be checked and expects to receive back an echo within a predefined time.
• Response time allows performance to be assessed.
• If bandwidth consumption of pings is an issue, then the ping/echo detectors can be organized in a hierarchy.
  • Low-level detector pings low level processes and higher level fault detectors ping lower level ones.

Heartbeat

• One component emits a heartbeat message periodically and another component listens for it.
• Absence of heartbeat means originating component has failed.
• Heartbeat messages can be combined with useful data.

Exceptions

• Exceptions encountered during operation.
• Exception handler is invoked which typically executes in the same process that introduced the exception.

Fault Recovery

• Fault recovery consists of preparing for recovery and making the actual system repair as well reintroduction of components after repair.

Preparation and Repair Tactics

Voting

• Processes running on redundant processors each take equivalent input and compute a simple output value that is sent to a voter.
• Voter detects deviant behaviour from a single processor - then it fails it.
• Different choices of voting algorithm - "majority wins" or "preferred component".
• Often used in control systems to correct faulty algo's or processors.

Active Redundancy (Hot restart)

• There are N redundant components - all of which respond to events in parallel.
• Response/output from only one component is used though and rest are discarded.
• Downtime is minimal, because backups are current and time to recover is only the switching time.
• E.g. LAN with a number of parallel paths and redundant component in a separate path.
• Synch is done by ensuring that all msgs to any component are sent to all redundant components, therefore a reliable transmission protocol may be required.

Passive Redundancy (Warm restart)

• One component (the primary) responds to events and informs the other components (the standbys) of status updates.
• When a fault occurs, backup state on standby must be fresh before resuming services.

Spare

• Standby spare platform.
• Must be rebooted to the appropriate software config and the state must be initialized to the point where the failure occurs.
• Therefore checkpoints of the system state must be made regularly.

Repair Tactics / Component Reintroduction

• When a redundant comp fails, it may be reintroduced after it has been repaired.

Shadow operation

• The previously failed component may be made to run in shadow mode to mimic behaviour of working components for a short time before making it operational.

State resynchronization

• Restored component must have its state upgraded before return to service.
• Ideal approach to update the state is a single atomic message. Incremental state upgrades lead to complicated software.

Checkpoint/Rollback

• A checkpoint is recording of consistent states either periodically or in response to specific events.
• System can be restored using a previous consistent checkpoint and a log of transactions since the last checkpoint was taken.

Fault Prevention

Removal from Service

• Removes a component from operation to undergo activities to prevent anticipated failures.
• For e.g. rebooting a component regularly to prevent memory leaks from causing a failure.
• Arch strategy must be designed to support it.

Transactions

• Bundling together of several actions so that entire bundle can be undone at once.
• If one action is failed, entire transaction is failed.
• Intermediate data doesnt corrupt output and affect rest of system.
• Lock shared data - threads.

Process Monitor

• Detect and shutdown failed processes,
• New process instance created and state recovered.

Modifiability Tactics

• Goal is to control time and cost to implement, test and deploy changes.

Localize Modifications

• Goals of tactics is to assign responsibilities to modules during design such that anticipated changes will be limited in scope.

Maintain semantic coherence

• Responsibilities should work together without excessive reliance on other modules.

Abstract common services

• Makes modifiability easy.

Anticipate expected changes

• Considering set of future changes helps to evaluate assignment of responsibilities.

Generalize the module

• Make a module compute a broader range of functions based on input. For e.g. constants can be passed in as input parameters.
• Basically, more general a module is, the more likely that requested changes can be made by adjusting the input rather than by modifying the module.

Limit possible options

• Restricting possible change options can reduce effect of modifications.
• For e.g. restrict processors to only be members of a certain family - limits the option and reduce the effect of modifications.

Prevent ripple effects

• A ripple effect from a modification is the necessity of making changes to modules not directly affected by it.
• Various types of dependencies one module can have on another:
  • Syntax of data and service.
  • Semantics of data and service.
  • Sequence of data : e.g. protocol sequence
  • Sequence of control: e.g. A must have executed no longer than 5ms before B executes.
  • Identity of an interface of a module: Id (name/handle) of an interface of A must be consistent with assumptions of B.
  • Runtime location of A: For B to exec correctly.
  • QOS of service/data provided by A. e.g. accuracy must be within a certain range.
  • Existence of A: For B
  • Resource behaviour of A: e.g. use of memory or resource ownership.

Hide Information

• Oldest technique. Hide private data.

Maintain existing interfaces

• Creating abstract interfaces to mask variations.
• Add interfaces, adapters, providing a stub (proxy pattern).

Restrict communication paths

• Reduce the no of data providers and consumers to and from the module.

Use an intermediary

• For non semantic dependencies, add an intermediary b/w B and A that manages activities associated with the dependency.
  • Data (syntax) : Convert syntax from A to B's.
  • Service (syntax) : Facade, Proxy, Factory : provide intermediaries that convert syntax of a service from A to B.
  • Identity of an interface: Broker pattern
  • Location of A (Runtime) : Name server. LDAP etc.
  • Resource behaviour: Introduce a resource manager.
  • Existence of A: Factory pattern.

Defer Binding Time

• Time to deploy and allowing non developers (sys admins and end users) to make changes.
• Tactics:

• Runtime registration: Pub/sub registration.
• Config files: set params at startup.
• Polymorphism: Late binding of method calls.
• Component replacement: allows load time binding.
• Adherence to defined protocols: Allows runtime binding of independent processes.

Performance Tactics

• Goal of performance tactics it to generate a response to an event arriving at the system with some time constraint.
• Main thing is to control the time within which a response is generated - the latency.
• Two basic contributors to resource time:
  • Resource consumption: CPU, database, network, memory, internal entities such as buffers. All these contribute to latency.
  • Blocked time: Blocking can happen due to various reasons:
    • Contention: Multiple events compete for the resource.
    • Availability: Resource may be unavailable for some reason (e.g. failure - network down)
    • Dependency on other computation: For e.g. data must be cached from DB before it can be read - this can cause latency.

Resource Demand

One tactic is reduce the resources required:

Increase Computational Efficiency

• Use efficient algorithms.

Reduce computational overhead

• Eliminate intermediaries (for e.g. RMI - adds lot of overhead)
• This is a trade-off between modifiability and performance.

Another tactic is to reduce the number of events processed:

Manage Event Rate

• Reduce sampling rate - there can be unnecessary oversampling.

Control Frequency of Sampling

• If no control over the arrival of external events - queued requests can be sampled at lower frequency.

Control the use of resources

Bound execution times

• Place a limit on how much exec time - for e.g. limit the time given to an algo.

Bound queue sizes

• Control max no. of queued arrivals.

Resource Management

• What if resource demand is not controllable, mgmt of resources affect response times.

Introduce Concurrency

• Parallelizing processing can reduce blocking times.

Maintain multiple copies of either data or computations

• In client-server architecture use caching to reduce contention.

Increase available resources

• Faster processors, additional processors
• Add more memory, network bandwidth.
• Trade-off between cost and performance.

Resource Arbitration

• Whenever there is contention for a resource, the resource must be scheduled.
• Basically, a scheduling policy for the resource.
• Scheduling policies can be:

FIFO Scheduling

• All requests for resources are treated equally and are satisfied in turn.

Fixed Priority Scheduling

• Assign each request a particular priority and assigns resources in that priority.
• Priority can be assigned according to
  • Semantic importance: According to domain characteristics.
  • Deadline monotonic: Higher priority to shorter deadlines.
  • Rate monotonic: Higher priority to streams with shorter periods.

Dynamic Priority Scheduling

• Round robin: Orders requests and assigns resource to next request in round robin order.
• EDF: Assigns priorities based on pending requests with the earliest deadline.

Static Scheduling

• Sequence of assignment of resources is determined offline.

Security Tactics

• Can be divided into three types of tactics : resting attacks (e.g. lock), detecting attacks (e.g. sensor), recovering from attacks (e.g. insurance).

Resisting attacks

• Address the requirements of security of a system.

1. Authenticate users: Users are who they claim to be. Passwords etc.
2. Authorize users: Authenticated user has the rights to access and modify either data or services. Access Control Systems etc.
3. Maintain data confidentiality: Encryption, public key authentication.
4. Maintain integrity: Redundant information encoded in it - e.g. checksums, hash results.
5. Limit exposure: Attacks typically all data & services on a single host. Architect can design allocation of services to hosts so that limited services are available on each host.
6. Limit access: Limit access from sources using firewalls. Establish DMZ. DMZ is a subnet that exists between the firewall protecting the internal LAN and the wider internet. Hosts within DMZ have limited connectivity to internal hosts while communicating with external hosts.

Detecting attacks

• Intrusion detection systems. e.g. compare network traffic patterns against known ones.
• Artificial immune systems
• Set traps

Recovering from attacks

• Can be divided into restoring state and identifying attacker.

• Recovering state: related to availability tactics.
  • Especially maintain redundant copoes of sys admin data such as passwords, ACL's, and user profile data.

• Tactics for identifying attackers: Maintain an audit trail. Audit can be used trace actions of attacker, support non repudiation and support system recovery.

Usability Tactics

Runtime Tactics

• Support user initiative:
  • Undo, redo, aggregate: All require architectural consideration.

• Support system initiative:

• Maintain a task model: Task analysis. e.g. auto correct beginning of sentences to capital.
• Maintain a model of user: e.g. Personas. How much the user's knows about the system, users behaviour in terms of expected response times. e.g. Page scrolling rate.
• Maintain a model of the system: Determines expected system behaviour so that appropriate feedback can be given to user. e.g. time needed to complete certain activity.

Design time Tactics

• Separate UI from rest of application: Allows UI developers to frequently change the UI and maintain code separately.
• Classic design pattern to implement this tactic: Model-View-Controller (MVC).

Testability Tactics

Manage input/output

• Record/playback:Capture information crossing an interface and use it as input to the test harness.
• Separate interface from implementation: Stubbing implementation allows rest of system to be tested in absence of stubbed component.
• Specialize access routes/interfaces: Have specialized testing interfaces.

Internal Monitoring

• Built in monitors: Record events when monitoring states have been activated. Increased visibility into activities of the component.